Direct Participation of Electrical Loads in the California Independent System Operator Markets During the Summer of 2000

TitleDirect Participation of Electrical Loads in the California Independent System Operator Markets During the Summer of 2000
Publication TypeConference Paper
Year of Publication2001
AuthorsChris Marnay, Kristina Hamachi LaCommare, Mark Khavkin, Afzal S Siddiqui
Conference NameEuropean Council for an Energy Efficient Economy Summer Study
Date Published06/2001
Conference LocationMandelieu, France
Keywordsdemand response, electricity markets, Load as a Resource

California's restructured electricity markets opened on 1 April 1998. The former investor owned utilities were functionally divided into generation, transmission, and distribution activities, all of their gas-fired generating capacity was divested, and the retail market was opened to competition. To ensure that small customers shared in the expected benefit of lower prices, the enabling legislation mandated a 10% rate cut for all customers, which was implemented in a simplistic way that fossilised 1996 tariff structures. Rising fuel and environmental compliance costs, together with a reduced ability to import electricity, numerous plant outages, and exercise of market power by generators drove up wholesale electricity prices steeply in 2000, while retail tariffs remained unchanged. One of the distribution/supply companies entered bankruptcy in April 2001, and another was insolvent. During this period, two sets of interruptible load programmes were in place, longstanding ones organised as special tariffs by the distribution/supply companies and hastily established ones run directly by the California Independent System Operator (CAISO). The distribution/supply company programmes were effective at reducing load during the summer of 2000, but because of the high frequency of outages required by a system on the brink of failure, customer response declined and many left the tariff. The CAISO programmes failed to attract enough participation to make a significant difference to the California supply demand imbalance. The poor performance of direct load participation in California's markets reinforces the argument for accurate pricing of electricity as a stimulus to energy efficiency investment and as a constraint on market volatility.


The attached file is a preprint version of an article accepted for publication in the Proceedings of the European Council for an Energy Efficient Economy Summer Study, June 2001. To see the published article, go to the url below or click here.

LBNL Report Number